Sweet Fanny Adams

“Killed a young girl – it was fine and hot”
The tragic tale of Sweet Fanny Adams

In Alton cemetery stands a gravestone, worn by time and the elements, but bearing witness to an event which not only shocked an entire nation but also introduced a new phrase to the English language.

“Sacred to the memory of Fanny Adams, aged 8 years and 4 months, who was cruelly murdered on Saturday, August 24th,1867”.

Now, almost 150 years after her death, the name of Fanny Adams is remembered, or at least used, by people all over the world and yet few know of the terrible fate that befell this innocent child. For the murder coincided with the introduction of tinned meat in the Royal Navy and the sailors, unimpressed with the new food, said the tins contained the remains of “Sweet Fanny Adams” and the expression, nowadays interpreted as meaning ‘sweet nothing’, has stayed with us.
So, to the name of this child who gained immortality through the cruel humour of sailors we are adding a story – a story based, not on hearsay or gossip, but on eye-witness accounts taken from the local and National newspapers of the time. Accounts which bring the horrific murder so to life that we can almost share the emotions and anger felt by this peaceful little community almost 150 years ago.

This is the true story of Sweet Fanny Adams.

On the fateful day of Saturday, August 24th, 1867, three young girls, Fanny Adams, her younger sister Elizabeth, and a friend, Minnie Warner, who like Fanny was eight years old, left their homes in Tanhouse Lane to play in the local meadows. The Lane, adjacent to the River Wey, was one of several leading up into the hop gardens which at that time were Alton’s main industry and covered the hillsides surrounding the town. From the Lane it was only a short walk past the watercress beds to Flood Meadow, a favourite spot on a hot summer’s day, where children could paddle in the safety of the shallow river and parents would picnic in the shade of the overhanging trees.

It was towards this idyllic spot that Fanny and her companions made their way just after 1pm. They had not gone far when they were approached by Frederick Baker, a 29 year old clerk with the local solicitors firm of William Clements. Baker, of “sallow complexion, 5ft 4in. high, weighing 8st. 10lbs” and looking much younger than his twenty nine years, offered Fanny a halfpenny to go with him up The Hollow, an old road leading to Shalden, by the side of a hop garden. At the same time he gave Minnie three halfpence to take Elizabeth home. With the money in her hand Minnie watched as Baker carried Fanny bodily into the hop fields; the last time she would see her friend alive. But, in the innocence of youth, she did not realise that anything was amiss and continued playing with Elizabeth until 5pm, when they went home. A neighbour, Mrs. Gardiner, saw the girls return and, on hearing about Baker and Fanny, immediately fetched Mrs.Adams and the women set of in search of the missing child. They had only gone a short distance when who should they see but Baker walking from the direction of The Hollow towards a footbridge across the Wey. Mrs.Gardiner shouted to him to stop and asked “What have you done with the child?”, to which he replied “Nothing”, although he did not deny having given the children some money earlier that day. Mrs. Gardiner questioned him at length about Fanny, but the quiet way in which he answered, combined with the respectable position he held in business convinced the two women of his innocence and, apologising, they returned home, assuming that Fanny was playing in the fields and would return before dark.

Seven o clock came and there was still no sign of the child.
By this time it was obvious that something had happened to her and a search party was formed. In their hearts they must have feared the worst, but the sight that met their eyes as they entered the hop garden at the top of the Hollow Lane was enough to turn the stomach of even the strongest man.

The report in the Hampshire Chronicle for 31st August 1867 was most explicit:-
“Soon after entering the hop-garden previously mentioned, and on looking about, the head of the missing child was picked up, with a gash evidently inflicted by some sharp instrument from the mouth to the ear, and another cut across the left temple. presenting a hideous sight. The left ear was cut off. On further search, a sickening spectacle presented itself, completely paralysing for a time those engaged in the shocking task of search.
The poor girls’ head was severed from the trunk, as stated, the eyes gone, apparently gouged out; both legs and one arm cut off, and one foot detached from the leg; the abdomen slit up, bowels and heart torn out, and the body scored about the back. All the parts, with the exception of the entrails, an arm, and a foot, which were scattered about the hop-garden, were found on Saturday evening.”

With the cry ringing round the hop gardens of “The head is found”, the people of Alton knew in their own minds who was responsible for this horrible crime. Many had seen Baker earlier that day in and around The Hollow; he had even been seen with the children and, when questioned by Mrs. Gardiner, had not denied giving Fanny some money that afternoon. On hearing of his daughter’s fate, George Adams left a cricket match on The Butts, a green in Alton still bearing that name, and collecting a loaded shotgun, set out for the hop gardens after Baker.

Meanwhile, as an angry crowd gathered outside William Clements’ solicitors office in the High Street, Superintendent William Cheney was inside, arresting Frederick Baker for the murder. Baker had returned to the office from the Swan public house, where he had been seen drinking heavily. Leaving the office by a back door, to avoid the crowd, the prisoner was taken to Alton police station where he was searched. Two small fancy knives were found in his possession, one of which was slightly bloodstained. The police also found traces of blood on both wristbands of his shirt and on his trousers. His left boot and sock and the leg of the trousers were wet. When the blood on his wristbands was pointed out, Baker rubbed his hands together and, after staring at them for a while, remarked: “Well, I don’t see a scratch or cut on my hands to account for the blood.” As for his trousers being wet, Baker, seemingly unconcerned, replied: “Well, that won’t hang me, will it?”

On the Sunday the hop gardens were swarming with people anxious to see for themselves where the murder had taken place and, over the next few days, the distressing search for the remains of Fanny Adams continued. William Henry Walker, a painter, searching near the spot where the head had been found, discovered a stone covered with blood and hair, and a small piece of flesh. This stone was seized upon as the weapon by which the young girl was killed. Indeed, Dr.Louis Leslie, MD, the Alton divisional police surgeon who made the post-mortem examination, was certain that death was caused by a blow on the head, probably with a stone.

The most damning evidence of all was found on the Monday afternoon by Superintendent Cheney searching Baker’s office desk. He found a diary put away behind some law papers, and, under the heading “Saturday, 24th August” was this entry, in the prisoner’s own handwriting, “Killed a young girl – it was fine and hot.”
These nine simple words as good as tightened the hangman’s noose around Baker’s neck, at least as far as the people of Alton were concerned, and the next day at the coroner’s inquest, in the Dukes Head Inn, the jury took just fifteen minutes over their verdict. Baker was committed to Winchester gaol to await trial at the next assizes.

By now the grief and horror felt by the little Hampshire town was shared by the whole country, with national newspaper reports adding to the sensationalism of the gruesome murder.

The Standard of August 29th, 1867 stated:
“No tiger of the jungle, no jackal roaming famished about a city of the dead, could so fearfully have mutilated its victim. In the middle ages the deed would assuredly have been attributed to a ghoul or vampyre…..”
The Telegraph, not to be outdone, wrote:
“If a savage wild beast had appeared in the green Hants fields and ravaged the farmer’’s flocks, it would not be so strange as the sudden apparition of a ferocious human being who could take a girl-child from her companions at play, and, after unspeakably brutish treatment, chop her body into pieces, and scatter them about the soil like the leavings of a tiger in the jungle….”

On Thursday, December 5th, Baker appeared before Mr. Justice Mellor at the Castle, Winchester. Following the prosecution’s case the only defence witnesses seem to have been called with regard to Baker’s character and, through them, a picture emerged of a highly disturbed young man. Dr.H.S.Taylor, a surgeon from Guildford, told the jury that Baker’s father had shown an inclination to assault, even kill, his own son and daughter; Baker’s cousin was insane and had been in an asylum four times; his sister had died of brain fever and Baker himself had attempted suicide after a love affair ended.

Mr. Justice Mellor reminded the jury that if they found Baker guilty, they had two choices: “death” or “not guilty on the grounds of insanity”.

Nowadays there would surely have been no doubting Baker’s insanity. The jury, however, returned a guilty verdict and Baker was condemned to death. He was executed in front of a crowd of 5,000 people at the county gaol, Winchester, on Christmas Eve, 1867.

Curiously, the hideous crime was not even mentioned in the definitive History of Alton, written just 29 years later, in 1896, by William Curtis. And today, though the name of Sweet Fanny Adams lives on, the reason why has been almost totally forgotten.

Back to Memories